How the No Surprises Act Is Reshaping Healthcare Costs for Self-Funded Employers

How the No Surprises Act Is Reshaping Healthcare Costs for Self-Funded Employers

The No Surprises Act was designed to protect patients from unexpected medical bills, but for self-funded employers, the law’s Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR) process has introduced a different challenge: rising plan costs.

Since the law took effect in 2022, the volume of disputes between healthcare providers and health plans has grown dramatically. Georgetown University’s Center on Health Insurance Reforms reported that federal agencies initially estimated approximately 22,000 disputes annually. Instead, 2.6 million disputes were initiated in 2025, followed by another 1.75 million during the first half of 2026.

For employers funding their own health plans, these disputes matter. Higher payments to out-of-network providers, administrative expenses, and IDR fees can ultimately become additional costs absorbed by the plan.

As employers prepare for 2027, understanding where these expenses originate, and taking steps to reduce unnecessary out-of-network utilization, should be part of the broader benefits strategy.

1. Understand What Your Claims Data Is Telling You

The first step is visibility.

Self-funded employers should work with their benefits advisor, third-party administrator, and network partners to understand how often their plan is encountering out-of-network claims and where those claims are occurring.

Rather than simply reviewing total healthcare spend, employers can dig deeper into the data to identify patterns. Are certain facilities generating a disproportionate amount of out-of-network activity? Are particular specialties creating recurring issues? Are employees receiving care from out-of-network providers even when appropriate in-network alternatives are available?

Identifying these trends allows employers to move from reacting to claims after they occur to developing strategies that address the underlying sources of cost.

For employers with larger populations or more complex claims activity, ongoing claims analysis can also help uncover opportunities for network optimization, plan design changes, vendor evaluation, and employee education.

2. Make It Easier for Employees to Find Quality, In-Network Care

Employees do not intentionally set out to create expensive claims. In many cases, they simply do not know where to go.

Healthcare networks can be complicated, provider directories can be difficult to navigate, and even an in-network facility can sometimes involve providers with different network arrangements.

That makes healthcare navigation increasingly important.

Employers can help employees understand how to verify network status, compare care options, locate appropriate providers, and make informed decisions before receiving non-emergency care. Depending on the population, this may include enhanced navigation resources, advocacy services, telemedicine, centers of excellence, second-opinion programs, or other tools that guide members toward high-quality, cost-effective care.

The goal isn’t simply to tell employees to “stay in network.” It is to give them the resources they need to actually do it.

When employees can more easily access quality in-network care, employers have a greater opportunity to reduce unnecessary out-of-network claims while also improving the member experience.

3. Take a More Active Role in Your Health Plan Strategy

Self-funding gives employers greater visibility and flexibility, but it also means the employer ultimately carries much of the financial impact when healthcare costs increase.

According to research from Georgetown University’s Center on Health Insurance Reforms, the estimated cost associated with the federal IDR process reached $22.4 billion between 2022 and 2025. That estimate included payments awarded above typical in-network rates as well as administrative expenses and IDR-related fees.

For employers, this reinforces the importance of treating health plan management as an ongoing strategy rather than an annual renewal exercise.

Employers should be asking their advisors and partners questions such as: How much out-of-network utilization are we seeing? What is driving it? How is our network performing? Are there opportunities to steer care more effectively? What vendors or programs are actually producing measurable value?

As scrutiny of the federal IDR process continues, employers and industry organizations may also play a larger role in advocating for changes intended to create a more sustainable dispute-resolution system.

Looking Ahead to 2027

The No Surprises Act remains an important consumer protection, but protecting employees from surprise bills does not eliminate the underlying cost of healthcare. In a self-funded arrangement, those costs can still find their way back to the employer-sponsored health plan.

Employers cannot control every claim or every IDR decision. They can, however, improve visibility into their data, strengthen employee navigation, evaluate the performance of their networks and vendors, and proactively address areas of unnecessary spending.

At Innovative Benefit Planning, we help employers look beyond the renewal and understand what is actually driving their healthcare costs. Through data analysis, strategic plan management, employee education, and ongoing evaluation of benefits partners, we help organizations identify opportunities to control costs while continuing to put their people first.

As healthcare continues to evolve, having the right strategy, and the right partners, can make all the difference.

Most Recent Media

Check Out Our Videos

A patient lies on an examination table beside a modern MRI machine while a medical professional reviews notes.
Image featuring the text What Clients Say About Innovative over a blurred background of a meeting, highlighting client testimonials.
Text overlay promoting a video on diabetes management and prevention, featuring a doctor and patient in a clinical setting.
  • RECERTIFICATION PROVIDER HRCI
  • Best of the Biz
  • 2024 Top-rated Employee Benefits
  • BCCC Business Excellence
  • SHRM RECERTIFICATION PROVIDER
  • Certified WBENC
  • CENTRE FOR FIDUCIARY EXCELLENCE
  • SOC TYPE
  • UBA Partner Firm
  • RECERTIFICATION PROVIDER HRCI
  • Best of the Biz
  • 2024 Top-rated Employee Benefits
  • BCCC Business Excellence
  • SHRM RECERTIFICATION PROVIDER
  • Certified WBENC
  • CENTRE FOR FIDUCIARY EXCELLENCE
  • SOC TYPE
  • UBA Partner Firm